Amazing X-Men Batman Columns Doomsday Clock Games Harley Quinn Hot Five JSA Special Features The Walking Dead Top Stories

H5*: Ten, Five, One – November 2018

H5*: Ten, Five, One - November 2018

Welcome to the primary month-to-month installment of “Ten, Five, One” the place we make a journey again in time. The newest addition to the H5* household will look again on the Diamond gross sales charts from ten years, 5 years, and one yr in the past and use these charts as a springboard for dialogue. Whereas there can be gross sales speak after taking a look at gross sales charts, this month-to-month column will even be used to debate developments, tales, occasions, and creators through the years, and the way all of these contributed to the modifications we’ve seen through the years. So sit again and put together to try a few of the business storylines within the comedian books utilizing points that have been launched ten, 5, and one yr in the past this month.

Observe: Any gross sales determine speak featured numbers taken from the charts over at whose meticulous documentation of comedian gross sales to the Direct Market through the years is a useful useful resource for these . Be certain that to go examine them out and be able to fall into a comic book gross sales rabbit gap.


1) Jeph Loeb and David Finch Ship Their Ultimatum

The highest promoting comedian of November 2008 was the debut of the now notorious Ultimatum. For the primary eight years of its existence, the Final Universe was an indication of high quality. There was no cause to consider that the celebrity artistic staff of Jeph Loeb and David Finch wouldn’t proceed that development. As an alternative, that phantasm was shattered with this miniseries, and in some ways the imprint would by no means recuperate. At the least Finch delivered on his finish of the discount, as this comedian seems to be excellent.

2) Batman RIP Concludes In Batman #681

Batman RIP had been one of the anticipated Batman tales since Hush ended about 5 years earlier. Grant Morrison’s Batman is among the all time nice runs with the character, nevertheless it’s protected to say this hyped story arc fell slightly flat. It was fairly complicated for a comic book that DC marketed like a can’t miss occasion for all Batman followers, and never simply these following the continued run. Even then it was a little bit of a multitude for these of us who had learn each situation. All of this regardless of the robust artwork from Tony Daniel. Or perhaps the issue was that Batman didn’t even die on this comedian, however somewhat over in Ultimate Disaster. That left readers a bit perplexed on the level of RIP. With that stated, the subsequent part of Morrison’s tenure was arguably the collection that cemented his run as a basic. Following a battle for the cowl to determine who would substitute Bruce we might be getting Batman & Robin, and I’m positive we’ll me speaking extra about that within the months forward right here.

three) Alex Ross Stuns With JSA Kingdom Come Particular: Superman

Of the highest 25 greatest promoting comics in November 2008, four have been JSA titles spinning out of the “One World, Under Gog” story arc. Geoff Johns’ Justice Society Of America noticed a number of points of the basic Kingdom Come introduced into common continuity, and these have been explored extra absolutely in a set of 1-shot specials. Probably the most spectacular of the bunch was the Superman particular, and with it being the primary comedian EVER absolutely written and illustrated by the good Alex Ross it was no shock that it was additionally one of the best promoting of the bunch. The gross sales of 72,848 was ok to squeak into the highest ten on the ninth spot.

four) Keep in mind The Strolling Lifeless Earlier than The Strolling Lifeless?

The Strolling Lifeless shipped two points in November 2008, and neither lit up the gross sales chart. Difficulty #54 got here in on the 82nd spot with 24,089 models bought, and #55 moved 23,881 which was good for 86th general. To place this in perspective the newest concern of the collection clocked in at 18th with 60,814 models bought whereas the 15th Anniversary Version of the primary situation was the second highest promoting comedian of October with 106,090 bought. Why the large discrepancy? Properly, again in November of 2008 we have been nonetheless 23 months away from the debut of AMC’s TV adaptation that may change the course of the franchise endlessly.

5) Creator Owned Comics Are Nonetheless Discovering Their Approach

With the whole lot within the above entry stated, these problems with The Strolling Lifeless have been nonetheless the perfect promoting comics from Picture Comics. Sure, it took 81 entries earlier than the gross sales chart noticed the primary comics from Picture, and people two problems with TWD have been 2 of solely three Prime 100 titles for the writer. In truth, there was just one creator owned title forward of TWD. Gerard Approach and Gabriel Bá’s Umbrella Academy: Dallas #1 from Darkish Horse Comics got here in at 50th for the month. four în the Prime 100 (Umbrella Academy: Dallas, The Strolling Lifeless x2, Spawn), 5 within the Prime 125 (BPRD: The Warning). Out of every part on this article the expansion of the creator owned indie market has been the most important story of the previous decade, particularly whenever you discover what number of extra publishers are discovering a market in 2018.


1) A New X-Males Collection Debuts To Huge Numbers

Virtually precisely 5 years previous to this week’s Uncanny X-Males relaunch, Marvel efficiently launched one other excessive profile X-Males collection with Jason Aaron and Ed McGuiness’ Superb X-Males coming in at quantity three for the month with 112,337 models bought. The difficulty featured the lengthy awaited return of Nightcrawler, and was launched to rave critiques, together with an ideal 10 and difficulty of the yr choice from yours really on this very website. Right here’s what I stated about Superb X-Males #1 for the Comicosity Yr Finish Listing, once I named it my Single Problem Of The Yr:

“No comic book put a smile on my face quite like Jason Aaron and Ed McGuiness’ Amazing X-Men #1. The return of Nightcrawler was everything I wanted it to be and then some. I can honestly say that the first 12 pages of this issue are as fun as I’ve had with a superhero comic in a long time. No other issue of any other comic this year made me wish I was a kid again so I could go run around outside and play pirates without looking ridiculous. There were other issues of other books with more serious emotion, and more gravitas, but I read comics as entertainment. The most important part of entertainment is having fun and Amazing X-Men #1 was as fun as it gets.”

2) Harley Quinn Debuts To Large Numbers And Some Controversy

Harley Quinn #zero was the launched on November 20, 2013. It was the primary solo collection that includes the eponymous former psychiatrist because the 38th and final difficulty of her first ongoing collection dropped on November 10, 2003. The brand new collection was written by the fantastic spouse/husband group of Amanda Conner and Jimmy Palmiotti with artwork from a who’s who of massive identify expertise with names like Darwyn Cooke, Sam Kieth, Tony Daniel, Artwork Baltazar, Becky Cloonan, Jim Lee, Bruce Timm, Jim Lee, Charlie Adlard, Stephane Roux, Tradd Moore, Adam Hughes, Dave Johnson, Dan Panosian, Walt Simonson, and eventual collection common artist Chad Hardin. With a lineup of artists that spectacular to go alongside the stellar writing staff of Palmiotti and Conner, it’s no shock the comedian was a smash hit, because it bought 114,212 models, or greater than each comedian that wasn’t an outsized problem of Batman. This debut situation proved to the world, and prime DC brass, that Harley was a star past her relationship with the Joker.

The collection wasn’t with out controversy although, as DC held a contest with a prize of drawing one web page on this challenge. The corporate caught flack for a panel description that includes Harley in a tub surrounded by electronics. The fear was that potential suicide was getting used for laughs in a public description getting used for a contest. Amends have been made, and the panel didn’t make it into the ultimate product from contest winner Jeremy Roberts. The controversy didn’t cease the title from being an enormous hit for DC, and it continues to be a constant performer 5 years on.

three) Massive 2 = Huge Occasions

Each Marvel and DC Comics launched massive occasion books in November 2013. Marvel was simply ending up the large Infinity story by Jonathan Hickman, and numerous artists. This occasion would mark the end result of Hickman’s runs on Avengers and New Avengers to that time with every of these collection tying in very intently with the primary mini. The story has solely acquired extra consideration over the previous yr with a number of parts of the story enjoying out on the large display within the newest Avengers film.

In the meantime over at DC Geoff Johns and David Finch have been three points into Perpetually Evil. Now that Johns’ run on Justice League looks like a distant reminiscence, this occasion appears to have virtually been forgotten, regardless of being a properly informed story whose results on the DC Universe can nonetheless,be felt at occasions at the moment.

four) What A Distinction 5 Years Makes

By 2013, The Strolling Lifeless was an enormous TV present whose comics bought very nicely. The 2 points launched on this month ranked 13th and 14th in gross sales with a mean of about 69,000 models bought. The newest TPB assortment at that time was on prime of the graphic novel chart with over 25,000 models bought. That doesn’t appear to be a lot till you understand that it completed with over 3x the quantity bought than the ebook that got here in second. The concept comedian e-book properties that make the leap to different mediums don’t assist out comedian has been confirmed proper for probably the most half, however The Strolling Lifeless seems to be an enormous exception.

5) Final Universe: Final Stand

At one level within the early the Final Universe was the envy of the comedian e-book world. The imprint was stored small with solely prime flight creators engaged on the few titles that have been being revealed. The technique labored, and the comics have been a few of, if not the most effective promoting comics of the interval. Within the very first entry on this very article I discussed Ultimatum being a downturn for the imprint. Inside 5 years the launch an Final Universe occasion went from being the perfect promoting guide of the month to the 35th greatest promoting comedian. That’s an enormous drop off, and searching on the numbers comparatively from this view helps make sense of why Marvel would ultimately reduce ties with the imprint in 2015 after yet one more try at a rebrand (which I’m positive we’ll get to on this column ultimately).


1) Doomsday Clock Debuts

Doomsday Clock, from the fashionable legendary artistic group of Geoff Johns and Gary Frank, made It’s a lot anticipated debut in November of final yr. The hype was so huge that the primary points took the TOP TWO SPOTS on the Diamond Prime 300. There was quite a bit written concerning the morality of latest Watchmen tasks as regards to Alan Moore’s views on the matter, bit regardless of the misgivings this problem bought like gangbusters. A yr later and we’ve solely seen six extra points, with the eighth scheduled for subsequent week (12/5/18). The delays and scheduling mixed with a little bit of a slower construct have all however killed the excitement for what had seemed to be a universe altering mega occasion that answered many questions introduced in 2016’s a lot celebrated DC Universe: Rebirth Particular. The unhappy half is that the comedian has gotten higher and higher with every situation. The magic might not have the ability to be captured once more from a hype perspective, however let’s hope Johns and Frank proceed to ship the products the remainder of the best way.

2) DC Dominates The Prime Of The Charts

Eleven of the highest 13 spots on the gross sales chart have been crammed with points revealed by DC precisely a yr in the past. The corporate was driving excessive off the continued success of Rebirth with Tom King’s Batman coupled with curiosity within the Darkish Nights: Metallic occasion, and the aforementioned launch of Doomsday Clock. DC had three points over 100,000 models bought with Doomsday Clock coming in at over 240,000 bought to the Direct Market. To say the corporate was on a roll is an understatement.

three) The Massive 2 Are The Huge 2

Through the years there have been occasions the place creator owned comics from outdoors the Massive 2 have began to make in roads with the Direct Market. There was a time just some years again when corporations like Picture have been the speak of the city. A few of that pale only a bit, and it actually exhibits within the charts. Outdoors of The Strolling Lifeless coming in at 14th, there was no non Huge 2 comedian within the prime 83 spots. 82 of the 83 greatest promoting comics only one yr in the past have been revealed by both Marvel or DC. That’s to not say that indie publishers weren’t profitable by their very own metrics with the books they have been publishing, particularly outdoors of the Direct Market, however simply goes to point out how a lot of a stranglehold the Massive 2 have on this distribution technique.

four) Al Ewing Is Underrated

U.S.Avengers was an incredible workforce comedian with a tremendous author and a comic book whose title has the phrase “Avengers” in it. You’d assume it will promote nicely, however you’d be mistaken. Problem #12 barely bought over 12,000 models and got here in at #165 in gross sales for the month. Ewing taking over an enormous Inhumans story that includes the royal household continued to falter as Royals #11 got here in at #176 with simply over 11,000 bought. I don’t get how a author that good could possibly be writing fairly rattling good comics that promote that poorly.

5) Why “Bat-Privilege” Exists

On the web some individuals use the idea of “Bat-Privilege” to complain about something from the variety of titles with the character’s identify on the duvet to issues that occur within the comics themselves. Properly, you recognize why that exists? Batman sells. Not solely have been spots three-6 taken up by Batman associated points this month final yr, however 5 years prior in November 2013 it was one of the best promoting comedian of the month. Then ten years in the past in 2008 it was quantity two on the charts. With simply the eponymous Batman title itself you will have three totally different artistic groups with three totally different takes on the character that each one completed with prime 5 points in November 2008, 2013, and 2017. That mannequin of consistency is one thing that you simply don’t see with some other comedian. That, my buddies, is an enormous cause why Batman is handled the best way he’s by DC Comics and their creators.